Uniforms keep firefighters safe on duty, but more and more is known about the long-term negative effects of their use. Dr Piotr Szewczyk from the Faculty of Metals Engineering and Industrial Computer Science has an idea for nonwoven fabrics which could be used in uniforms and not cause such side effects.
Sometimes, the only thing that separates a firefighter from mortal danger is their outfit, the uniform that is supposed to protect them from flames. However, the research published over the recent years challenges the assumption that the protection provided to firefighters is adequate and sufficient (you can read about it here). Reports suggest that the increased incidence of cancer in the group of firefighters is due not only to the frequent exposure to smoke and fumes of burning materials or chemicals, but also to the carcinogenic materials used during the manufacture of their uniforms.
Dr Piotr Szewczyk aims to develop fireproof unwoven fabrics which, even when damaged or in direct contact with flames, will not emit substances harmful to human health. Owing to his project concerning refractory electrospun nonwoven fabrics of high mechanical durability, Dr Szewczyk received funding within the MINIATURA 8 call for applications by the National Science Centre.
“That is an occupation risky in itself. It would be the right thing to do to get rid of the risk arising from wearing clothing they need to wear,” said the researcher on the motivation behind the improvement of firefighter suits. “Currently, firefighters often have no choice because there are no other materials that offer, for example, similar mechanical properties at a given temperature, so they prefer to work in potentially carcinogenic uniforms rather than give up the protection that separates them from losing their health and lives.”
Commercially available suits for use in the high-risk sector often contain the so-called PFASs, or per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, which in certain forms are harmless and resistant to high temperatures. The latest research, however, convinces us that, as a result of damage to their structure, they begin to secrete harmful substances that can adversely affect human health and, in particular, contribute to the formation of cancers. Similarly to Teflon – an undamaged frying pan coating is inert and cannot negatively affect our health, but when scratched it begins to release carcinogenic compounds, and so too can a damaged firefighter's suit. PFASs will begin to release and affect human health in negative ways. Unfortunately, such damage during rescue operations is not uncommon. According to the current state of knowledge, firefighter uniforms may contribute to the epidemic of cancer in firefighters.
The nonwoven fabric that Dr Szewczyk is working on is to consist of fibres coated with nanoparticles, which will provide the polymers with protection against combustion and eliminate the problem of the release of harmful substances.
The AGH University researcher intends to produce nonwovens using electrospinning. It is a technique that allows nonwovens to be obtained from polymers to which different molecules can be added at the production stage. The work starts with the preparation of a solution – the polymer, from which the fibre is to be made, is dissolved in a specific solvent. This solution is then introduced into a syringe, which is mounted in a pump. From there, the solution goes into a nozzle, which is usually a needle. The key point is that this nozzle is at a high voltage, of the order of tens of kilovolts, and there is a collector several centimetres away. This creates a very strong electrostatic field between the needle and the collector, which starts to pull out the polymer stream, and it starts to deposit on the collector, usually a metallic cylinder. The polymer stream is so thin that all the solvent that is in the solution evaporates before it reaches the collector.
The challenge is that the molecules that are supposed to form the top, fire-resistant layer of the fibre cannot mix with the polymer, they should wrap around it and form a kind of buffer zone instead.
“It is on the outside that the so-called core-shell technology is used, that is, we have a core made of a polymer and on the outside there is a second needle from which we can administer another polymer or, for example, nanoparticles in a solvent. Then, these particles, coming out of the nozzle, combine with this fibre, which is produced as a result of electrospinning, and we obtain a structure with a polymer inside and particles protecting it on the outside,” the researcher explained.
Nanoparticles of soot have the properties required to cover the fibres. Soot is created by combustion. It consists of the most basic carbon compounds which are inert and non-flammable. What was supposed to burn has already burned out, so we are dealing with an effect resistant to the process. What is more, large amounts of soot are created as a waste material in the oil and gas industry, so finding new ways to manage it is highly useful. Similar compounds may be created from burnt coffee beans. There is no shortage of them in the world, and they would serve as more than a product to be composted. Nanoparticles of soot can be obtained simply by grinding the microparticles in a mortar into finer fractions or using more sophisticated ball mills.
“The plan is to make these particles as small as possible and, when the burning of the fibre is to take place, the fire will encounter a barrier of carbon which cannot burn (at least not at the temperatures we are dealing with in this case), so it forms a protective barrier. My objective is for these materials not to start to burn at all and not to produce any harmful chemicals,” explained Dr Piotr Szewczyk.
The smaller the particles, the tighter they will be able to surround the polymer and the more effective they will cut off the access of oxygen, thus a fireproof barrier is formed. Moreover, the presence of said nanoparticles increase the durability of polymer fibres (which are durable themselves). Yet another advantage of soot. The polymer chains become entangled with nanoparticles that collect stresses, which allows for higher loads to be carried.
Ceramic nanoparticles could also be used to create such a layer, but although it is a frequently used and effective method, it is also very expensive. Also, it requires the use of harmful chemicals, such as concentrated trifluoroacetic acids, so the use of soot appears more environmentally friendly and safer.
The fibres created in the electrospinning process are very thin. To the naked eye their appearance can be compared to that of a handkerchief, but their durability is many times greater. For comparison: microfibres are fibres with a diameter of less than 10 microns and nanofibres are less than a micron in diameter. Those studied by Dr Szewczyk have a diameter of 700-800 nanometres, so 10 times less. The thinner the fibre, the more useful it gets.
The uniforms that are currently popular are very thick and restrict the firefighter's movements to a large extent, getting in the way. At present, we lack technology which would provide freedom of movement and adequate insulation, as it is most easily achieved through thick layers of material. Electrospun nonwovens can be used to coat virtually any type of material with virtually no increase in volume. The fireproof membrane that the AGH University scientist is working on would not constitute the entire outfit, but only one layer, effectively protecting against the impact of flames. Thus, it would give an opportunity for the firemen and firewomen to have more freedom.
Photo: AGH University
The allocated funds will allow the researcher to purchase the equipment necessary to examine the properties of the nonwoven fabrics developed. The first stages of the study will be done with the use of the apparatus that is already available at the AGH University, i.e. scanning electron microscope which can magnify up to 150 thousand times, thus it allows to observe the dispersion of soot particles on the surface of the polymer. An atomic force microscope will also be used in the research, which will allow the topography of such a fibre to be studied, the properties of the particles to be measured, and its thermal properties to be examined, which will inform us how effectively the material dissipates heat and, therefore, whether it performs well as a fire barrier.
“There are several ways to see the fibres in depth. One of the techniques is to break the fibres in liquid nitrogen, which is a simple, cheap, and quick solution. The fibres are placed in liquid nitrogen and then cut with a razor blade, which causes them to break due to freezing. These cracks reveal the internal structure of the material. Gallium ions can also be used to cut through the material in a scanning microscope. If necessary, a more advanced and time-consuming technique, such as transmission electron microscopy, can be used, which also allows to obtain a cross-section of the fibres,” said the researcher.
However, we would need to purchase new equipment to carry out normative combustion tests, and thus confirm or refute the achievement of the intended effect in the developed nonwovens.
If tests confirm that the developed nonwoven fabric has all the properties predicted in the project, it will be possible to attempt to apply it on mass scale. There are already some companies in the world that produce materials by electrospinning. They found a use, for example, in the production of face masks, which were in great demand during the pandemic. If, on the other hand, the technology should prove to be very expensive for the time being, the scholar sees an opportunity to apply and develop it in the space or military industry, as in these areas budget constraints play a less significant role than the usefulness of innovative solutions.
“My duty as a scientist is to keep on trying to develop this material, be interested in finding a solution and making it available to the world. At this stage I am not thinking about a patent. (...) If we manage to develop such a fire-resistant nonwoven fabric, it would show other researchers that we are able to produce a material that has similar properties but without using harmful chemicals. It is a complicated approach, but in my opinion the game is worth playing, because the public is getting more and more information on microplastics, the chemicals that stay in the soil forever, and that they migrate from the soil to the water, from the water to the plants, and from the plants to the animals, and from them to us. The circle closes and you have to try to actively fight it. I'm not saying ‘ecology at all cost,’ but where it can be done, we should make that additional effort,” concluded the scientist.
Dr Piotr Szewczyk is a member of Electrospun Fibers Group managed by Professor Urszula Stachewicz at the Faculty of Metals Engineering and Industrial Computer Science. The group specialises in advanced research in the field of materials engineering, particularly polymer fibres. More information on its activity and latest projects may be found at fibers.agh.edu.pl.